9800X3D vs. R5 5600, Old PC vs. New PC: Intel Arc B580 Re-Review!

The video re-evaluates the Intel Arc B580 graphics card’s performance when paired with the Ryzen 5 5600 and Ryzen 9 9800X3D, highlighting significant performance drops in CPU-intensive games when using the slower CPU. It concludes that the B580 is better suited for users with more powerful CPUs, as its value diminishes in CPU-limited scenarios compared to competitors like the RTX 4060 and RX 7600.

In the video, the host revisits the Intel Arc B580 graphics card, particularly focusing on its performance when paired with different CPUs, specifically the Ryzen 5 5600 and the Ryzen 9 9800X3D. The re-review is prompted by previous findings regarding the B580’s overhead issue, which causes performance degradation in CPU-limited gaming scenarios, especially noticeable with slower CPUs. The host emphasizes the importance of understanding these performance variations and mentions that the video will include new data from 12 games tested at various settings and resolutions.

The testing reveals that the B580 performs well in some titles when paired with the Ryzen 5 5600, showing only minor performance declines in certain games at 1080p and 1440p resolutions. For instance, in games like “A Plague Tale: Requiem” and “Dragon Age,” performance remains stable, with negligible drops in frame rates. However, in more CPU-intensive games like “The Last of Us Part One” and “Cyberpunk 2077,” the B580 struggles significantly, with frame rates dropping by as much as 29% compared to its performance with the more powerful Ryzen 9 9800X3D.

As the testing progresses, the host notes that the B580’s average performance across 12 games shows an 18% reduction when paired with the Ryzen 5 5600. In contrast, the RTX 4060 and RX 7600 GPUs experience much smaller performance hits of 4% and 6%, respectively. This indicates a concerning trend for the B580, which transitions from being faster than its competitors with the 9800X3D to noticeably slower when tested with the 5600. The B580’s value proposition diminishes as it struggles to compete effectively in CPU-demanding scenarios.

The video also explores the impact of upscaling on performance, revealing that enabling upscaling often benefits the competitors more than the B580. For example, in “Star Wars Jedi Survivor,” the B580 performs comparably at native resolutions but falls behind when upscaling is enabled. The host highlights that while the B580 shows strong performance in some scenarios, its overall value becomes questionable, especially when considering the need for a more powerful CPU to unlock its potential.

In conclusion, the host emphasizes that the B580 is not the best choice for users with slower CPUs, as its performance suffers in CPU-intensive games, leading to diminished value compared to Radeon and GeForce GPUs. The video suggests that the B580 is best suited for users with more capable CPUs, like the Ryzen 7 5700 or higher, to truly benefit from its capabilities. The host shares that Intel is aware of these findings and is investigating potential solutions, but optimism for a quick fix remains low. Ultimately, the video serves as a cautionary tale for potential buyers, urging them to consider their CPU’s capabilities before investing in the B580.